
Since the natural man is an enemy to God—and to His children—it should not surprise us that our natural inner voice can be uncivilized and unhelpful. When our children misbehave, our first response is often an accusation: “What were you thinking?” “What’s wrong with you?” “Why don’t you ever listen?”
Those questions are neither motivating nor informative. They are accusations masquerading as questions.
Of course, our accusing thoughts may arise from frustration, fatigue, fear, or habit. But Satan is delighted to encourage them. After all, he is the great accuser. He thrives on mocking, minimizing, and condemning God’s children.
Jesus offers a glorious alternative. He is our Advocate (see Doctrine and Covenants 45:3–5). At the final Judgment, He will plead His merits before the Father on our behalf. He will point to His own suffering and sacrifice and ask the Father to extend mercy to us:
“Wherefore, Father, spare these my brethren that believe on my name, that they may come unto me and have everlasting life” (Doctrine and Covenants 45:5).
What a friend we have in Jesus! What a blessing to have a heavenly Advocate!
The accuser looks for evidence of failure. The Advocate looks upon us with love and sees the possibilities for our redemption.
Consider Shannon’s experience.
One evening, Shannon’s mother was expecting company. She had been rushing around, attending to dozens of last-minute details. When she noticed that Shannon had neither done her homework nor taken her bath, she snapped at her daughter and delivered a lecture about responsibility.
Then Mom walked into the living room and discovered something unexpected. Shannon had been trying to help her by dusting and polishing the furniture.
Mom realized her mistake and hugged her earnest little girl. But company was arriving, and the moment was quickly forgotten.
Later that evening, after the guests had departed, Mom tucked Shannon into bed. As she turned to leave, she noticed tears forming in her daughter’s eyes.
“What’s the matter, dear?” she asked.
Shannon looked into her mother’s eyes and asked the question that had been weighing on her heart.
“Mom, why is it that when I do something bad, we talk about it so much? But when I try to do something good, it seems like I’m the only one who remembers?”
What a heartbreaking question!
And what a challenge to all of us who are parents! Why are we so quick to notice and discuss our children’s mistakes while so often overlooking their good intentions and earnest efforts?
Perhaps part of the answer lies in the conversations we have inside our own heads. When we repeatedly rehearse our children’s faults, we prepare ourselves to criticize them. When we look for their goodness, we prepare ourselves to encourage them.
The conversations we have with ourselves shape the conversations we have with our children.
Haim Ginott, the renowned child psychologist, encouraged us to become advocates for our children. That doesn’t mean ignoring their problems or pretending they have no limitations. It means deliberately looking for their goodness and possibilities. Ginott wrote:
“Nature always sides with the hidden flaw. [We] have the opposite role: to side with the hidden asset, to minimize children’s deficiencies, intensify their experience, and enlarge their lives.”
What a marvelous description of our opportunity as parents! We can side with the hidden asset.
When we are tempted to point an accusing finger at our children, we can challenge our natural inner voice. Instead of collecting evidence against our children, we can look for evidence of their goodness.
We might even recognize that some of their most troublesome behaviors are connected to their greatest strengths.
Nate’s stubbornness may be related to the determination that will someday help him accomplish great things.
Justin’s temper may arise, in part, from a tender heart that is easily wounded.
Beth’s whining may reflect her deep desire to belong and be included.
These possibilities don’t excuse misbehavior. They help us respond to it with understanding rather than condemnation.
Imagine a mother whose child refuses to cooperate. Her natural inner voice protests, “He’s deliberately trying to make my life miserable!”
But she challenges that accusation. “Wait a minute! Maybe he’s tired or discouraged. Maybe he’s feeling powerless. Maybe there’s something I don’t understand. What does he need from me right now?”
That simple exchange can change everything.
Instead of seeing an adversary to be defeated, she sees a child to be understood and guided.
The accusing voice urges us to find fault, assign blame, and demand compliance. The advocating voice invites us to understand, encourage, and teach.
We can choose which voice we will entertain.
Of course, as we subdue the natural man and cultivate the man or woman of Christ within us, our inner voice becomes increasingly trustworthy. We begin to hear the angels of our better nature. We become more inclined to see others as Jesus sees them.
But whenever our inner voice is filled with accusation, we would be wise to turn our backs on Old Scratch and follow the example of our heavenly Advocate.
We can refuse to rehearse our children’s faults. We can search for their strengths. We can look beneath their mistakes for good intentions, unmet needs, and growing capacities.
Satan would have us become prosecutors of our children. Jesus invites us to become their advocates.
And when we follow His example, we don’t merely improve our parenting. We help our children discover the goodness that God has planted within them.
Reflection
Think of a time when you were tempted to condemn or criticize one of your children but chose instead to understand or appreciate that child.
- What helped you replace accusation with compassion?
- How did that change your feelings and your response?
- What could help you challenge your accusing inner voice more often?
Applying This Strategy
☐ I ask Heavenly Father for help.
☐ I remember with gratitude my past successes with this strategy.
☐ I ask myself: Does this strategy fit me? If not, can I adapt it?
☐ I plan how I will respond the next time the challenge arises.
☐ I imagine myself replacing accusation with understanding and advocacy.
☐ I try it out.
☐ I keep refining my efforts—otherwise known as repenting.
Recommendation & Invitation
My favorite parenting book has always been Haim Ginott’s Between Parent and Child. No other book has done more to shape my understanding of how parents can replace criticism, anger, and control with compassion, respect, and understanding.
John Gottman shares my enthusiasm. He calls it “the most important book ever written on parenting and the emotional world of children” and urges parents to master the skills Ginott teaches.
What makes this book so remarkable is that Ginott doesn’t merely teach us how to manage children’s behavior. He teaches us how to understand their hearts, honor their feelings, and help them become emotionally healthy, responsible, and compassionate people.
If you read only one parenting book, I recommend this one. Read it slowly. Ponder its wisdom. Practice its principles. It may transform the way you see your children—and the way they experience your love.
Personal note: I had the privilege of helping revise Ginott’s original book for the current edition.
Reference
Haim G. Ginott, Teacher and Child (New York: Macmillan, 1972), 179.